The Stage


Shenton's View

The Phantom at 25

This coming Sunday, The Phantom of the Opera celebrates the 25th birthday of its official opening in the West End at Her Majesty’s on October 9, 1986, but over the weekend it jumped the gun by a week with a special, three-performance only new staging at the Royal Albert Hall.

Last night’s performance was also broadcast to cinemas around the UK and the world - a friend even texted from the Ziegfeld Theatre in New York to say that he could see me, seated in the 8th row of the main arena floor in front of the stage.

If the Vegas version of the show calls itself Phantom - the Las Vegas Spectacular — and whose original star Sierra Boggess was coincidentally reprising her performance as Christine from that show here, having subsequently originated the same role in the London production of Love Never Dies — I was expecting this production to have out-Vegased Vegas.

And it certainly looked the case on entering the Albert Hall, with a vast chandelier shrouded but visible from below hanging over the arena, and the box seats, including box 5 that the Opera Ghost himself specifies be left empty for his exclusive use but the new managers fatally disregard, cleverly being extended out of the tiers of the Royal Albert Hall itself.

The venue has therefore been smartly conscripted as part of the lavish design brief here, and an elaborate and spectacular proscenium constructed at what is usually the stage orchestra end that pays explicit tribute to the late Maria Bjornson’s miraculous original designs that Andrew Lloyd Webber himself paid specific tribute to in an onstage speech at the end, saying that the success of the show would never have happened without her.

But other key parts of the design were merely conjured by projections, and I really missed, for instance, the magical journey that the Phantom and Christine make through a candle-lit lake to his lair. The real place to see this is in a theatre, not on projections; I longed for 3D glasses to make them seem more real! Sadly, too, that shrouded, very real chandelier doesn’t fall - even on film! (The closest it comes to falling is on the cover image to the show’s lavish souvenir brochure).

On the other hand, as an opportunity to hear a full-blooded, very 3D rendition of one of Lloyd Webber’s lushest, most operatic scores, this was hard to beat, with an ace cast of full-voiced principals. Ramin Karimloo - who created the role of the Phantom in Love Never Dies after a long stint in the role in the London production of the original Phantom, and a prior stint as Raoul as well - was a sensational Phantom, at once yearning and passionate.

And reunited with Sierra Boggess from Love Never Dies, they had a ready-made chemistry that can’t be faked. Boggess brings her shimmering soprano and simmering personality to Christine that makes her as mysterious as she is beautiful, rather than merely simpering. It was great, too, to see Hadley Fraser — currently playing Javert in Les Miserables — bringing a glorious voice and romantically tousled charm to Raoul, a role he’s not played before.

A final curtain call walk down saw a reunion of the surviving original London cast of The Phantom of the Opera, including Michael Crawford (who sadly didn’t sing) and Sarah Brightman. Lloyd Webber introduced Brightman as “my angel of music”; the show had, after all, been written for her when they were married to one another, and as the story of a composer in thrall to a vivacious soprano, it has always been hard not to draw parallels between life and art.

There was also a line-up of other Phantoms, including legends Colm Wilkinson and Anthony Warlow (who created the roles in Canada and Australia), and our own John Owen-Jones, who is currently back in the role and should be a legend. I suppose they could not invite all the Phantoms who’ve made their mark in the role over the years, but it would have been nice to see Peter Karrie and Howard McGillin, who have each played over 2,500 performances in the role from London, Canada and the Far East in the case of Karrie, and on Broadway in the case of McGillan.

It would also have been a good touch to have seen the world’s longest-serving Phantom cast member George Lee Andrews, who spent some 23 years in the Broadway incarnation, playing a total of some 9,382 performances in various roles, until his contract was not renewed last month, as I reported at the time.

There are, of course, plenty of ways to try to explain the phenomenon of The Phantom of the Opera and its amazing longevity: in last Saturday’s Daily Telegraph, Max Davidson suggested that “it is a textbook example of herd behaviour. If A, B and C are doing something, D, E and F have to do it, too” and went on to call it “The Mousetrap with tunes, a habit, a cultural ritual, a tourist attraction, Something You Have to Do While You Are in London.”

But it’s a lot more than an exercise in cultural hypnosis. It’s that rare thing, a show that crosses social and international barriers to speak to audiences genuinely and not just because everyone else is going anyway. I’m glad I went last night. But I want to see the show in the theatre again now. And after last night’s finale, John Owen-Jones is the man I want to see!


Howard McGillin, Mark, with an 'i', not an 'a'. Now that Cameron has had two ego boosting special events for Les Miz and Phantom, one could ask of both Mr. Mackintosh and ALW - what have you done for us lately. Answer? Not much. It's hard to find parallels for a producer (CM) and composer (ALW), who have in the 25 years since their mega mega hits have so relatively little to hand their hats on. Look at David Merrick's record - a real producer if there ever was one. Or R&H or Kander and Ebb who kept writing new shows.

Could we perhaps celebrate the future rather than dragging these, now cash cows, through the world?

And is CHICAGO really going to take the Garrick off the market for the next 10 years? One more West End theatre gone.

Seems there always has to be someone to rain on a parade.

Lewis in mine and thousands of others worldwide's opinions Phantom of the Opera (and Les Miz) are phenomenons that deserve every accolade and celebration that they have received.

I am waiting in anticipation for the somewhat delayed cinema release here in Australia from the 13th of what by all accounts was a stunning concert!
Would have been lovely to see George Lee Andrews included - hopefully when they celebrate the 25th anniversary on Broadway they will remedy that.

The concerts are never going to replicate the intimacy and atmosphere that the theatre brings but from what I hear this moved thousands to tears and Ramin, Sierra and Hadley sizzled.

I'm actually seeing this tonight and I can't wait. I'm a fan of Sierra's and have heard nothing but positive reviews of her performance. Personally, I don't think it's a case of cultural hypnosis. As Hal Prince once was one of the few truly romantic musicals. On top of this, my introduction to Phantom was actually through a mini series starring Charles Dance...i didn't actually even hear Andrew Lloyd Webber's for 5 years after i saw that as a child. So the theory Max Davidson came up with doesn't really apply to myself anyhow. I feel there is something special in the story itself...everyone, on some level can relate to the man. We've all been lonely and outcast at some point. I'd say most of us have loved and not been loved back at one time or another as well. I'm especially looking forward to seeing the Final Lair in this concert as I've heard it's absolutely heartbreaking.

"Mr. Mackintosh and ALW - what have you done for us lately. Answer? Not much. "
Only 2 amazing concerts for Les Miz and POTO. And the heartbreaking Love Never Dies and the awesome new version of Les Miz. POTO movie, and soon a Les Miz movie .....not much, really.

Totally agree with you Lewis - do they want to turn the West End into the theatrical equivalent of Madame Tussauds? Such a shame that both anniversary 'celebrations' suffered from unambitious casting and shameless greed on the part of the producers. Still, it's nice to see John Owen-Jones getting a well-deserved mention Mark - and how ironic that he was marginalised in the celebrations of both Les Mis and Phantom despite his considerable talent and association with both roles. In our opinion one of the great unsung heroes of the West End. And why is Colm Wilkinson always so underused at these occasions? We saw him in concert in Dublin two years ago so we know he's still got what it takes. C'mon Colm, let's have a London concert!

rageoffstage- I'm sorry but if you saw this concert I find it hard to believe one can't give credit where credit is due to Sierra and Ramin. Both did a phantastic job and I was blown away by Sierra most of all. I think she has more than proven herself for sure. While I prefer a more classical sound as opposed to Ramin's..his acting was amazing..especially in the 2nd act and I loved that unlike most Phantom's...he attempted to impersonate Piangi in PONR voice wise (as he should...he's in disguise.) So kudos to the two leads. They were amazing. That being said I understand about JOJ and as for Colm Wilkinson...he already did a lead in Les Miserables 10th anniversary's not like he's not been immortalized...I think it's nice to give new talented people a chance as well as respecting the old.

Was it really broadcast to cinemas across the UK?! Cineworld in Aberdeen (Queen's Links branch) told us at 19.05 that the live feed had failed, that all cinemas suffered the same problem. They turned off the screen, saying that the RAH crew had announced the problem couldn't be fixed. Did they lie?!

Recent Comments

Augustine on The Phantom at 25
Was it really broadcast to cinemas acros...
Krista Andrese on The Phantom at 25
rageoffstage- I'm sorry but if you saw t...
rageoffstage on The Phantom at 25
Totally agree with you Lewis - do they w...
221B on The Phantom at 25
"Mr. Mackintosh and ALW - what have you ...
Krista Andrese on The Phantom at 25
I'm actually seeing this tonight and I c...
Kym on The Phantom at 25
Seems there always has to be someone to ...
Lewis Marlowe on The Phantom at 25
Howard McGillin, Mark, with an 'i', not ...

Content is copyright © 2012 The Stage Media Company Limited unless otherwise stated.

All RSS feeds are published for personal, non-commercial use. (What’s RSS?)