The Stage

Blogs

TV Today

Doctor Who 4.12: The Stolen Earth

Well thank you very much Russell T Davies! How on earth do you review that, eh? Perhaps the most bonkers, delicious, audacious, brilliant, silly, exciting and scary piece of Doctor Who seen in the 45-year history of this crazy, unstoppable TV series. The Stolen Earth had a bombastic confidence about it that was thankfully a million miles away from the beginning of last year’s two-part run around finale with The Master.

From the off, it’s obvious Davies has approached this with the intention of going out with a copper bottom pop. You can imagine him cracking his knuckles as he sat down to work on the script for The Stolen Earth, thinking: “I’m never going to be able to do this again in my life, so let’s just go for it!” And go for it he has.

There is so much crammed in here it’s difficult to know where to start, but the plot is actually beguilingly simple. Somebody has, quite literally, nicked the Earth from under the noses of the Doctor and Donna, forcing the Time Lord to shunt off to the dramatically sinister sounding Shadow Proclamation to see what’s to do. The Shadow Proclamation might sound dramatically sinister, but the reality is far from it - it’s actually a beige set somewhere with some cheap Ikea furniture.

While the Doctor and Donna are given a fiver to go to the pictures and keep out of the way of the plot, it’s up to some touchstones set up in the Doctor Who universe over the last four years (and beyond) to sort everything out. Martha Jones, Captain Jack and Torchwood, and Sarah Jane Smith (complete with son Luke and supercomputer Mr Smith) are trapped on an Earth that is out of time and space and surrounded in a darkened sky by other planets.

And then the Daleks burst in…

When I was a kid I loved those Marvel Comics team-ups when you’d have Spider-Man teaming up with Captain America and the X-Men. This is the Doctor Who equivalent and it’s pant-wettingly exciting. Some of the audience will never have seen Torchwood, some will never have seen The Sarah Jane Adventures, but it doesn’t matter. This is a celebration of where Davies has taken Doctor Who and just what has been achieved in four years. Doctor Who is literally a small television industry now, and it’s only right and proper that we get to see the spin-off shows brought together under the hospitable roof of the parent show.

That element aside, the Daleks make their mandatory annual appearance, and this is their best, perhaps most traditional outing to date. I love seeing Daleks trundling around spaceships having shouty conversations with each other; it’s how they were meant to be. There’s something quite satisfying hearing that familiar rasp vowing to “Annihilate UNIT!” (It’s even more satisfying to see that UNIT are as useless as ever at repelling alien marauders). Under Graeme Harper’s effervescent direction the pepper pots also look menacingly effective on the darkened streets of suburban Britain, herding families out of their homes for who knows what sinister purpose.

And of course, The Stolen Earth marks the long-awaited return of Davros, creator of the Daleks. It was always going to happen - after the Daleks themselves, the Cybermen and the Master, what was left? And he is so pitch perfect, it hurts. The visual look of Davros was always going to be a clincher, and the designers have chosen, very wisely, not to monkey around here. That emaciated frame, the half Dalek casing trundling through the shadows, a childhood sense memory encoded into the minds of grown ups of a certain age, and to tamper would have been a disaster. And now, a new generation of children will get to experience that thrill all over again.

Looks aside, Julian Bleach’s performance as Davros is what seals the deal. He has taken a halfway house between the original (and best) version as played by Michael Wisher, and the more exuberant, but no less enjoyable, turn by Terry Molloy in the 1980s. Bleach plays the inherent mania of the character with admirable understatement, but this is only the first episode - he has mercifully left himself somewhere to go for next week’s finale. I get the feeling he might need it.

This episode crams so much in (including the opening titles with all those names flying around!). Even Harriet Jones, former Prime Minister gets a look in, bringing Russell T Davies’s vision of Doctor Who full circle. Did he have a master plan when he first took on the riskiest job in TV drama? Probably not, but it all feels very neat and I’m happy to give the benefit of the doubt.

And what about that cliffhanger? You know my feelings on Rose. I find her annoying, smug and spoilt, but now I think that’s inherent within the character and the writing. Certainly I wanted to slap her as she’s having her ‘what about me?’ moment when Harriet brings the Children of Time together (love that name, by the way). But even the most flint-hearted must have had a misty eye as Rose found her Time Lord again and they ran towards each other in candy box slow-mo. And then cheered as this outpouring of romance was brought to an end, as it should be in Doctor Who, by a big Dalek gun…

And so we leave the Doctor, surrounded by his friends in the TARDIS, once again going through that wonderful, inexplicable change… If I was a betting man, however, I’d put money on David Tennant still being in residence at the end of next week’s episode, but sometimes with Russell T Davies, you never can tell…

If you haven’t got it already, I loved The Stolen Earth, possibly a touch more than is healthy. I don’t care, though. This was Doctor Who at its most show stopping, entertaining and brilliant best!

9 Comments

Just to counter on the Rose front - I find her dynamic, brilliant and brave. And yes, I did tear up when she and the Doctor ran towards each other. The look on the Doctor's face... conveyed everything.

The episode crammed so much in, it was like a veritable TARDIS itself. Small on the outside (45mins), huuuuge on the inside. Every other character got their time, rather than just wee cameos, which really made these programmes all brought together feel like a true 'Whoniverse'.

I don't think it makes storytelling sense to introduce a new actor in the very last episode of the series. And let us not forget, DT has already filmed the Christmas special. Of course there's ways round that (timey wimey stuff), but I really want to believe they'd let DT have his big moment in the finale.

Thanks so much... Amdist all the 'oooooh the wuv each other' Rose returns rubbish, someone who tells it like it is. I must have a heart made of total stone, however, as I cringed as they ran towards each other. Love the Tennant as I do, never was I so happy to see him shot ;-) However, I fear that the Rose love fest will up a notch this coming week. It will not be pretty.

I agree! Rose and the Doctor run towards each other had me thinking one thing- "When is a Dalek going to show up and spoil the moment". And true to form it did!

I doubt that Tennant will leave as there is too much in that episode that could have a reverse effect on that regeneration- The Medusa Cascade, His Hand in the Jar and the mere paradox that River Song reconised him in Silence in the Library and so did Queen Elizabeth in Shakespeare Code. This all leaves too much in the air for Tennant to leave.

Lastly i think we all have to admit that the production for this series is brilliant. No "Next Time", no Trailers, no Fear Factor(on the DW site), it all gives a fantastic feeling of suspense mastered by Russel T. Davies! Brilliant

Wow ! What an episode. And what a cliffhanger. I can't believe that they could have kept it quiet if DT was leaving but even so it is still is a real edge of the seat moment.

I'm so-so on the Rose front. Never liked the romancy angle but then (we assume) she's was the Doctor's first companion since the Time War & helped him to risk friendship again - so it is Ok to say she has a more intense relationship with him than others did.
I thought the "What about me" bit was very funny. It's a bit mean to be down on her for that when you consider that she's travelled accross universes & seems to have some pre-knowledge of what's happening. What she knows is important to the Doctor.

Who is the "Most Faithful companion" who's going to cop it next week ? Rose or Donna are most likely. Or is it like Rose's "death" mere word-play.

Where was K9 ? Yes, I know he's protecting Earth in the vortex thingy butI'm suprised they didn't at least mention him.

Let's hope next Saturday's episode lives up to it's promise.

btw: I keep having problems with your Captcha - Is it because it changes in the background if you take to long typing ?

I wasn't struck when I first watched this - in fact it has taken 4 viewings to see it as it is meant to be - cracking good family drama. Although even I could see that the bees were aliens - so Douglas Adams ("So long and thanks for all the nectar!)

I'm with the guys on the Rose/Doctor reunion - too long a road, too long a run, and too long a scene. Can't be all girly whirly on this - I'd have rather she appeared behind him, he turned, smiled, and went to embrace her then ZAP! Never waste time on a hug... I know she was special to the Doctor but really, bleugh!

I loved Davros and can't wait to see him up the ante next week, adored the poor frazzled Caan - Bless! K9 to save the day??? Or his he the most faithful companion and we've all been led down the Rose "wrenched from him again" path?

Come on Saturday - I'm an excited fangirl already!

Even though I did the exact same thing when the Dalek arrived to save the day, I couldn't stop laughing at "And then cheered as this outpouring of romance was brought to an end, as it should be in Doctor Who, by a big Dalek gun…"!
*wipes tear from eye* ahh good times. Nice review.

'Certainly I wanted to slap her as she’s having her ‘what about me?’ moment when Harriet brings the Children of Time together'

I felt sorry for her that she was seeming to be left out since it was a big get together and she'd come so far. I certainly wanted to slap Martha during her much more whiny and selfish comment during the Human Nature/Family of Blood story when she realised the Doc had fallen for someone else (actually I want to slap Martha most of the time. She annoys me more than any other companion in Doctor Who history...except maybe Mel). Please make her be the one to die.

Great episode though. And I actually did jump up off my couch at the cliffhanger and think what the hell? Most exciting and thrilling episode of any show I've seen in recent years. Good work to the crew, cast and everyone who kept that cliffhanger a secret. I had forgotten how nice it is to be surprised.

Just rewatched the amazing The stolen Earth and wondered if anyone else noticed that just before the regeneration scene when the Doctors talking he says,
“I’m sorry. It’s too late… i’m regenerated.”
Not i’m regenerating, but regenerated, wonder if that could be significant for tomorrow nights episode

I love Dr. Who, and since i am in the usa and we get the show a season after you I was happy to find this page! i am a fan of Rose, but I do like Donna as well. but I realy love Capt John. James Marsters is so dreamy. have you heard him on the dresden files audio books? check out at http://www.buzzymultimedia.com/storm-front-audiobook-by-jim-butcher.html

Loading
Subscribe to The Stage Podcast (iTunes edition) Square Eyes: Twice weekly TV previews Turn off the TV: TV Today's radio picks

Recent Comments

terri on Doctor Who 4.12: The Stolen Earth
I love Dr. Who, and since i am in the us...
Doctor Dude on Doctor Who 4.12: The Stolen Earth
Just rewatched the amazing The stolen Ea...
Carn on Doctor Who 4.12: The Stolen Earth
'Certainly I wanted to slap her as she’s...
Bianca on Doctor Who 4.12: The Stolen Earth
Even though I did the exact same thing w...
Dawn on Doctor Who 4.12: The Stolen Earth
I wasn't struck when I first watched thi...
Sue on Doctor Who 4.12: The Stolen Earth
Wow ! What an episode. And what a cliffh...
James on Doctor Who 4.12: The Stolen Earth
I agree! Rose and the Doctor run towards...
Jules on Doctor Who 4.12: The Stolen Earth
Thanks so much... Amdist all the 'oooooh...
Emmy on Doctor Who 4.12: The Stolen Earth
Just to counter on the Rose front - I f...

Content is copyright © 2012 The Stage Media Company Limited unless otherwise stated.

All RSS feeds are published for personal, non-commercial use. (What’s RSS?)